County Commissioner Sarah Arnold, former St. Augustine Beach Mayor (and current City Commissioner) Dylan Rumrell and County Commissioner Christian WhitehurstCounty Commissioner Sarah Arnold, former St. Augustine Beach Mayor (and current City Commissioner) Dylan Rumrell and County Commissioner Christian Whitehurst
County Commissioner Sarah Arnold, former St. Augustine Beach Mayor (and current City Commissioner) Dylan Rumrell and County Commissioner Christian Whitehurst. | St. Johns County, St. Augustine Beach

Charges against St. Johns officials dropped in fake voter guide case

Published on November 19, 2026 at 4:37 pm
Free local news and info, in your inbox at 6 a.m. M-F.

Criminal charges against three St. Johns County elected officials in the case of a 2024 fake voter guide have been dropped.

Former St. Johns County Commissioner Sarah Arnold and current County Commissioner Christian Whitehurst and St. Augustine Beach City Commissioner Dylan Rumrell were all charged with misdemeanors for their alleged involvement in the distribution of a voter guide that mimicked an actual St. Johns Republican Party voter guide ahead of the 2024 elections. 

Jacksonville Today thanks our sponsors. Become one.

The three were charged alongside Jamie Johnson and campaign manager Briana Jordan, who worked with Whitehurst and other local elected officials. 

In a written statement Thursday, the legal team representing the three elected officials called the investigation “a disappointing waste of taxpayer resources.”

In a statement to News4Jax, the judge on the case said that a ruling on the charges against Jordan would come at a later date.

The fake voter guide next to the real one.
The fake voter guide, on the left, is shown next to the real one. | News4Jax

Last week, the officials’ attorneys argued that the charges should be dropped for falling outside of a two-year statute of limitations.

Many St. Johns County voters received the voter guide that appeared to be from the local Republican GOP and included candidates, like Whitehurst, that the party had not endorsed. 

Denver Cook, head of the local GOP, says he hopes prosecutors appeal the dismissal of the case. He calls the guide “a clear-cut case of election fraud” and says the defense deliberately ran the clock out on the case.

This is a developing story. At time of publication, court documents from the St. Johns County Clerk of Court were not yet available.


author image Reporter email Noah Hertz is an award-winning reporter focusing on St. Johns County. Noah got his start reporting in Tallahassee and in Wakulla County, covering local government and community issues. He went on to work for three years as a general assignment reporter and editor for The West Volusia Beacon in his Central Florida hometown of DeLand, where he helped the Beacon take home awards from the Florida Press Association.