Attorney Andy HaleAttorney Andy Hale
Attorney Andy Hale, right, was joined by police shooting victim Brian Gillis' mother, Melody Gissentanner, at a Nov. 18, 2026 news conference as a federal suit against the city and a Jacksonville police officer was announced. | News4Jax

Lawsuit alleges excessive force in fatal police shooting of 30-year-old Jacksonville man

Published on November 18, 2026 at 2:34 pm
Free local news and info, in your inbox at 6 a.m. M-F.

The mother of a 30-year-old Jacksonville man who Jacksonville police shot and killed last year has filed a federal wrongful death lawsuit alleging excessive force.

An officer with the Jacksonville Sheriff’s Office shot Brian Gillis on Aug. 13, 2025.

Jacksonville Today thanks our sponsors. Become one.

At a Wednesday news conference, attorneys for Gillis’ mother announced the federal suit naming the city of Jacksonville as well as Officer Caleb Bumgarner.

Chicago-based attorney Andy Hale said that Brian Gillis was in the middle of a documented mental health crisis at the time of the shooting.

“He was no threat at all to any JSO officer,” Hale said. “Deadly force is only supposed to be used if you are in fear of imminent death or bodily harm. It is a last resort. It is an awesome power that the police have to use deadly force, but it comes with awesome responsibility. You can only use it as a last resort, when you have no choice.”

The Jacksonville Sheriff’s Office told Jacksonville Today it is “unable to comment on pending litigation.”

Gillis’ mother, Melody Gissentanner, was at the news conference, though she did not speak.

Attorney Jason Marx related what happened on Aug. 13, 2025, saying that Gissentanner was the one who called police when her son had apparently tried to set a neighbor’s home on fire. The attorney said she wanted them to take him into custody under Florida’s Baker Act.

An officer with the Sheriff’s Office’s Behavior Crisis Response Unit responded just before 8 a.m., joined by licensed mental health clinician.

The officer and clinician questioned Gillis and spoke to one of the neighbors, who said that she “just want to see him get some help,” Marx said. Then Gillis fled from the scene before he was found by Bumgarner just after 9 a.m. a few blocks away, Marx related.

That is when Bumgarner did “everything against his training,” according to Marx, by ordering Gillis to come to him and threatening to have his K9 bite him. Gillis eventually turned around with a knife in his hand before running away again, Marx said.

That’s when, Marx said, Bumgarner pulled out his gun and shot Gillis in his back. He died on East 25th Street near Buckman Street.

“Instead of Officer Bumgarner helping Brian, he continued commanding him to drop the weapon, drop the knife,” Marx said. “He said it about a dozen times.”

“Brian has done nothing,” Hale added. ” … There is no emergency here at all. And what’s the first thing he (Bumgarner) says? ‘You are going to get dog bit.’ Is that de-escalation?”

The lawsuit says the officer should have also used his own medical kit to stop the bleeding from Gillis’s gunshot wounds. Instead, Bumgarner continued to try to get the knife away from Gillis, who was “clearly incapacitated,” Marx said.

The suit also disputes the Sheriff’s Office’s description of the knife Gillis was holding. The police report called it a “large, unsheathed knife.”

This is the image of the knife that was released by the Jacksonville Sheriff’s Office after Brian Gillis’ fatal 2025 shooting. | Jacksonville Sheriff’s Office

Hale said his Chicago law firm handles a lot of police-involved cases there, and he called this one “shocking.”

“You really can’t wrap your head around how this can still be happening,” Hale said. ” … The bad apples need to be weeded out; they need to be held accountable and removed, and what’s frustrating, what I have seen in Jacksonville is that has not happened. Jacksonville deserves better; the people of Jacksonville deserve more.”

The attorneys also showed portions of body-worn camera footage released by the Sheriff’s Office, showing Bumgarner firing as Gillis ran, then calling for medical assistance.

The State Attorney’s Office has not released its opinion on whether any crimes were committed by the officer in the shooting.

The lawsuit is seeking compensatory and punitive damages, as well as attorneys’ fees.


author image Reporter email Dan Scanlan is a veteran journalist with 40 years as a radio, television and print reporter in the Jacksonville area, as well as years of broadcast work in the Northeast. After a stint managing a hotel comedy club, Dan began a 34-year career as police and current events reporter at The Florida Times-Union before joining the staff of WJCT News 89.9.