The Nease High School marching band on field at a competitionThe Nease High School marching band on field at a competition
The Nease High School marching band performs in a competition on Nov. 7, 2026. | Megan Mallicoat, Jacksonville Today

Ex-Nease band director, who left under investigation, changed name, kept teaching  

Published on November 20, 2026 at 1:54 pm
Free local news and info, in your inbox at 6 a.m. M-F.

At Nease, he was Michael Johnson, a name he legally changed before he went on to work for a school in Massachusetts — until his Florida allegations caught up to him this year. 

The former Mr. Johnson, now 49, was Nease High School’s band director for about 10 years until his 2017 resignation amid allegations of sexual misconduct involving a student. According to reporting by The Boston Globe, he worked at a suburban Boston school from 2024 until an anonymous tip to the newspaper and the district about Nease led to his firing this year. 

Jacksonville Today thanks our sponsors. Become one.

His Massachusetts school district tells Jacksonville Today, “His resumé listed extensive experience in teaching and band direction but omitted his tenure at the Florida high school from which he resigned after the allegations surfaced.” 

Neither The Boston Globe nor Jacksonville Today were able to make contact with the teacher most recently called Michael de Melo before publication. 

Pride of the Sunshine

In 2006, St. Johns County Schools hired a teacher who was then known as Michael David Johnson, a University of Florida grad who’d been a drum major in the school’s Pride of the Sunshine marching band. Johnson split his time between Nease and a few area middle schools, including Landrum and Fruit Cove, before going full time at the high school in 2009. Personnel records the district released in response to a request by Jacksonville Today show that over the years, supervisors praised his skill as a band leader while noting the need to improve his administrative and communication skills.

In 2008 and 2009, he received reprimands from Linda Thomson — now a member of the St. Johns County School Board, then the principal at Nease — for poor attendance, job performance and communication. His file also notes a 2010 internal investigation after a parent alleged that Johnson “intentionally embarrassed” a student.  

A more serious allegation came in 2016, when a student was injured in Johnson’s classroom and had to be treated for “multiple abrasions” on their face. Johnson initially said the incident was an accident caused by students roughhousing. However, further investigation revealed Johnson himself had been playing a game called “Mercy”— something the teacher described in a statement as locking hands and trying to bend each other’s wrists.

Records show the school district reported the incident to the Florida education department’s Professional Practices Office but the state declined to investigate.

In a written reprimand, Principal Kyle Dresback instructed Johnson to implement corrections, including ensuring that classroom activities “serve an educational purpose based on the scope of the content standards for your content area.” 

‘True physical relationship’

Around the same time, Nease leadership received an anonymous email alleging Johnson had a “true physical relationship with an underage student. And the potential of more than just one.” 

The sender messaged Nease administrators a few more times. Then-Principal Lisa Kunze responded, asking for names, “so we can get started” with an investigation. School leadership reported the allegation to the St. Johns County Sheriff’s Office that same day.

An SJSO investigator interviewed a Nease assistant principal and made contact with the anonymous emailer, who told the detective he and Johnson had “engaged in a sexual relationship” while he was an underage student. 

The report says the officer interviewed the accuser at “great length,” but does not include details because he asked that the conversation be kept “off the record.” 

The investigator later interviewed Johnson and asked if he’d ever had an “intimate relationship with a current or previous student.” According to his report, Johnson said he had, the year before, but he insisted it began “just after” the student’s high school graduation.

The officer closed the investigation in the spring of 2017, citing “lack of cooperation from the complainant and possible victim.” 

Likewise, a school district investigator’s notes say an alleged victim (unclear if he was the same accuser who spoke to police) “refused to compile a written or signed statement” and was only participating in the interview “so other students do not get hurt.” 

The student said Johnson first began messaging him via social media. Later, “the relationship became more intense” and included “sexual things.” 

“He is terrified that this will go out in public; he wishes to remain anonymous and wants to move forward with his life but is cooperating to stop [Michael Johnson] from doing any harm to other students,” the investigator wrote.

Other allegations

In the course of the dual investigations, other students said Johnson would “take his belt and flick it at students” — a practice that left welts, according to one — and some alleged Johnson had thrown scissors at students during a period of time when he’d temporarily lost his eyesight. The witnesses said they were “terrified, but luckily, no one got hurt.”

The internal investigation included observations from faculty, too.

One teacher described incidents they’d either allegedly heard about straight from Johnson or witnessed firsthand. It was “band tradition for males in band as seniors to wrestle Mr. Johnson on the final day of classes,” usually without their shirts, the statement alleged. Johnson denied wrestling with students when questioned by investigators, the notes show. 

The district suspended Johnson with pay on March 27, 2017, and he resigned about a month later. The district then closed its investigation and completed his final, post-employment evaluation with a rating of “effective” (the second-highest score a teacher could earn on a four-point scale). 

The documents show the district again reported Johnson to the state, which again declined to investigate. His Florida teaching license remained active until it expired in 2019.

From the west to the east

After leaving St. Johns County, Johnson found work as a band teacher at Gallup High School in New Mexico. In December 2018, though, parents there raised questions about his past at Nease. Media reports at the time said that the school district investigated him, but the outcome is unclear, and the district hadn’t responded to a request to comment by this story’s publication. 

In August 2020, Johnson contacted St. Johns County Schools to ask them to verify he had been employed. They complied, noting on a form that he’d had a disciplinary suspension with pay for about two weeks in March 2017.

Court records show Johnson changed his last name in February 2022 to Dampier.

As Michael Dampier, he was hired by Medford Public Schools in Massachusetts. 

That school district says he most recently went by Michael de Melo. Jacksonville Today was not able to independently verify the name change with legal records, but documents from a band competition last year seem to confirm the third name.

The Boston-area school district released a statement last month saying they’d properly vetted Johnson. He lied on his resume, they said, omitting his employment in Florida altogether and keeping them from connecting the dots to Nease.

In the statement, Medford Superintendent Suzanne Galusi said the district had received no “allegations of inappropriate behavior” during his roughly 18 months of employment there. 

Galusi promised to review the district’s hiring practices and called the teacher’s application an “elaborate effort to gain employment with our district under false pretenses.” 


author image Reporter email Megan Mallicoat is a Jacksonville Today reporter focusing on education. Her professional experience includes teaching at the University of Florida College of Journalism and Communications, as well as editing, communications management, web design, and graphic design. She has a doctorate in mass communication with an emphasis in social psychology from UF. In her "free time," you'll most likely find her on the sidelines of some kind of kids’ sports practice, holding a book.