PerspectivesRob Bradley Jacksonville Today Contributor
ImageImage

Opinion: Florida’s surgeon general fight is a preview of 2024

Published on February 9, 2022 at 7:01 pm

Before the 2000 Bush/Gore election, Tim Russert, the late Meet the Press host, was asked what he would be watching the most on Election Day. 

Russert scribbled out three words on his whiteboard: “Florida, Florida, Florida.” Of course, it turned out that the leader of the free world was decided in Florida that year by 537 votes. 

Not much has changed. Florida has remained the center of the American political universe since 2000. Consider the dominant political issue of our time: COVID.

As the country continues to grapple with how to deal with the virus, two leaders have come to represent two diametrically opposed strategies: President Joe Biden and Governor Ron DeSantis. They snipe at each other constantly, both directly and through proxies.


Sign up for the Jacksonville Today newsletter

Your local weekday newsletter for news and ways to get involved in Northeast Florida.

But for all of the potshots back and forth between the Biden and DeSantis camps over the past few months, there hasn’t been a face-to-face confrontation until last month at the state Capitol in Tallahassee. 

The setting for this Royal Rumble was a typically mundane, off-the-radar Senate Health Policy Committee meeting. 

In one corner was Dr. Joseph Ladapo, DeSantis’ choice for state Surgeon General, who was before the committee for a confirmation hearing. Ladapo has been an unapologetic skeptic of masks and lockdowns. His position on vaccines is that they are helpful but not a magic bullet. In short, he’s a walking and talking embodiment of the DeSantis “freedom first” approach to the virus but with a lab coat and Harvard medical degree. 

Ladapo’s ability to credibly deliver the DeSantis message on COVID remains critical to the governor’s political success. He is up for re-election this year and a top contender for president in 2024. 

In the other corner were Senate Democrats, who possessed the power in this hearing to directly ask questions of Ladapo. If they could discredit him they could, by extension, discredit the governor’s COVID response.

At the hearing, both sides understood the stakes. The political world seemed to understand it, too. This was the first time in memory that a state surgeon general confirmation hearing in Tallahassee received significant national news coverage. 

At the hearing, Ladapo expressed his well-documented skepticism of aggressive COVID mitigation measures. He also refused to apologize for his role in a previous kerfuffle with Democratic Senator Tina Polsky, D-Boca Raton, over not wearing a mask in her office for a scheduled meeting between the two (Polsky is battling breast cancer). 

During the hearing, Senate minority leader Lauren Book, D-Plantation, bore in hard, demanding yes or no answers to what she considered to be straightforward questions. Ladapo refused to say the magic words, insisting that the questions were in fact correctly answered with nuance rather than a simple yes or no. The Democrats walked out in protest before a vote was taken. 

Ladapo probably should have apologized for offending Polsky, even if he had to grit his teeth to do it. The Democrats probably should have been more respectful in their questioning and not walked out, even if they don’t like Ladapo or what he says. 

But that just wasn’t going to happen. The two sides are dug in, and they aren’t giving an inch until the voters declare a winner in 2024. 

Clearly, both sides now view any show or sign of compromise as weakness. The fight is the point. 

What we know for certain is that this is just the first of many bare knuckle battles in what will be an epic three-year political war in “Florida, Florida, Florida.”


author image Jacksonville Today Contributor Rob Bradley is an attorney and current chairman of the governing board of the St. Johns River Water Management District. Rob is managing partner of Bradley, Garrison & Komando, P.A., an Orange Park law firm. He represented the north Florida region in the Florida Senate from 2012-2020, serving as Chairman of the Senate Committee on Appropriations from 2017-2020, where he crafted three state budgets, each in excess of $90 billion.
author image Jacksonville Today Contributor Rob Bradley is an attorney and current chairman of the governing board of the St. Johns River Water Management District. Rob is managing partner of Bradley, Garrison & Komando, P.A., an Orange Park law firm. He represented the north Florida region in the Florida Senate from 2012-2020, serving as Chairman of the Senate Committee on Appropriations from 2017-2020, where he crafted three state budgets, each in excess of $90 billion.

Sign up for the Jacksonville Today newsletter

Your local weekday newsletter for news and ways to get involved in Northeast Florida.